Skip to main content
Back To Top Top Back To Top
The Legislative Service Commission staff updates the Revised Code on an ongoing basis, as it completes its act review of enacted legislation. Updates may be slower during some times of the year, depending on the volume of enacted legislation.

Chapter 5711 | Listing Personal Property

 
 
 
Section
Section 5711.01 | Listing personal property definitions.
 

As used in this chapter:

(A)(1) "Taxable property" includes all the kinds of property mentioned in division (B) of section 5709.01 and section 5709.02 of the Revised Code, and also the amount or value as of the date of conversion of all taxable property converted into bonds or other securities not taxed on or after the first day of November in the year preceding the date of listing, and of all other taxable property converted into deposits after the date as of which deposits are required to be listed in such year, except in the usual course of the taxpayer's business, to the extent the taxpayer may hold or control such bonds, securities, or deposits on such day, without deduction for indebtedness created in the purchase of such bonds or securities from the taxpayer's credits. "Taxable property" does not include such investments and deposits as are taxable at the source as provided in sections 5725.01 to 5725.26 of the Revised Code, surrender values under policies of insurance, or any tangible personal property acquired from a public utility or interexchange telecommunications company as defined in section 5727.01 of the Revised Code and leased back to the public utility or interexchange telecommunications company pursuant to a sale and leaseback transaction as defined in division (I) of section 5727.01 of the Revised Code. For tax year 2007 and thereafter, "taxable property" of a telephone, telegraph, or interexchange telecommunications company, as defined in section 5727.01 of the Revised Code, includes property subject to such a sale and leaseback transaction.

(2) For tax year 2007 and thereafter, taxable property leased to a telephone, telegraph, or interexchange telecommunications company, as defined in section 5727.01 of the Revised Code, other than pursuant to a sale and leaseback transaction, shall be listed and assessed by the owner of the property as follows:

(a) If the property leased to such a company is not governed by division (C) of section 5711.22 of the Revised Code in tax years 2007 and 2008, it shall be listed and assessed at the percentage of true value in money required under division (G) of section 5711.22 of the Revised Code.

(b) All property leased to such a company in tax years 2009 and 2010 shall be listed and assessed at the percentage of true value in money required under division (H) of section 5711.22 of the Revised Code.

(3) For tax years 2009 and 2010, the lessor of property subject to division (A)(2) of this section shall have the true value of the property the lessor leases to a telephone, telegraph, or interexchange telecommunications company determined under divisions (A)(5) and (E) of section 5727.06 of the Revised Code.

(B) "Taxpayer" means any owner of taxable property, including property exempt under division (C) of section 5709.01 of the Revised Code, and includes every person residing in, or incorporated or organized by or under the laws of this state, or doing business in this state, or owning or having a beneficial interest in taxable personal property in this state and every fiduciary required by sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, to make a return for or on behalf of another. For tax year 2007 and thereafter, "taxpayer" includes telephone companies, telegraph companies, and interexchange telecommunications company as defined in section 5727.01 of the Revised Code. The tax commissioner may by rule define and designate the taxpayer, as to any taxable property which would not otherwise be required by this section to be returned; and any such rule shall be considered supplementary to the enumeration of kinds of taxpayers following:

(1) Individuals of full age and sound mind residing in this state;

(2) Partnerships, corporations, associations, and joint-stock companies, under whatever laws organized or existing, doing business or having taxable property in this state; and corporations incorporated by or organized under the laws of this state, wherever their actual business is conducted;

(3) Fiduciaries appointed by any court in this state or having title, possession, or custody of taxable personal property in this state or engaged in business in this state;

(4) Unincorporated mutual funds.

"Taxpayer" excludes all individuals, partnerships, corporations, associations, and joint-stock companies, their executors, administrators, and receivers who are defined in Title LVII of the Revised Code as financial institutions, dealers in intangibles, domestic insurance companies, or public utilities, except to the extent they may be required by sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, to make returns as fiduciaries, or by section 5725.26 of the Revised Code, to make returns of property leased, or held for the purpose of leasing, to others if the owner or lessor of the property acquired it for the sole purpose of leasing it to others or to the extent that property is taxable under section 5725.25 of the Revised Code.

(C) "Return" means the taxpayer's annual report of taxable property.

(D) "List" means the designation, in a return, of the description of taxable property, the valuation or amount thereof, the name of the owner, and the taxing district where assessable.

(E) "Taxing district" means, in the case of property assessable on the classified tax list and duplicate, a municipal corporation or the territory in a county outside the limits of all municipal corporations therein; in the case of property assessable on the general tax list and duplicate, a municipal corporation or township, or part thereof, in which the aggregate rate of taxation is uniform.

(F) "Assessor" includes the tax commissioner and the county auditor as deputy of the commissioner.

(G) "Fiduciary" includes executors, administrators, parents, guardians, receivers, assignees, official custodians, factors, bailees, lessees, agents, attorneys, and employees, but does not include trustees unless the sense so requires.

(H) "General tax list and duplicate" means the books or records containing the assessments of property subject to local tax levies.

(I) "Classified tax list and duplicate" means the books or records containing the assessments of property not subject to local tax levies.

(J) "Investment company" means any corporation, the shares of which are regularly offered for sale to the public, engaged solely in the business of investing and reinvesting funds in real property or investments, or holding or selling real property or investments for the purpose of realizing income or profit which is distributed to its shareholders. Investment company does not include any dealer in intangibles, as defined in section 5725.01 of the Revised Code.

(K) "Unincorporated mutual fund" means any partnership, each partner of which is a corporation, engaged solely in the business of investing and reinvesting funds in investments, or holding or selling investments for the purpose of realizing income or profit which is distributed to its partners and which is subject to Chapter 1707. of the Revised Code. An unincorporated mutual fund does not include any dealer in intangibles as defined in section 5725.01 of the Revised Code.

Section 5711.02 | Annual returns - supplying of blanks.
 

Except as otherwise provided by section 5711.13 of the Revised Code, each year, beginning in tax year 2004, each taxpayer having taxable personal property with an aggregate taxable value in excess of ten thousand dollars shall make a return to the county auditor of each county in which any taxable property the taxpayer must return is required by this chapter to be listed. The taxpayer shall truly and correctly list on the return all taxable property so required to be listed, including property exempt under division (C)(3) of section 5709.01 of the Revised Code. Such returns shall be made on the blanks prescribed by the tax commissioner, which the county auditor shall supply at the auditor's office along with blanks of the kind required for the county supplemental return required by section 5711.131 of the Revised Code. The county auditor shall mail or distribute such blanks prior to the fifteenth day of February to all persons known to the auditor to be taxpayers and to all persons to whom the commissioner may direct blanks of either type to be mailed or distributed. The county auditor may place listing and county supplemental blanks at convenient places in the county. The failure of a taxpayer to receive or procure blanks shall not excuse the taxpayer from making any return or county supplemental return. The individual required to make the return shall furnish all statements and documents, give all information required, answer all questions asked on the required blanks, and subscribe to the truth and correctness of all matters contained therein.

Section 5711.03 | Listing of taxable property.
 

Except as provided in sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, all taxable property shall be listed as to ownership or control, valuation, and taxing districts as of the beginning of the first day of January, annually, except that taxable personal property and credits used in business shall be listed as of the close of business of the last day of December, annually, and deposits not taxed at the source shall be listed as of the day fixed by the tax commissioner for the listing of deposits taxed at the source pursuant to section 5725.05 of the Revised Code. The subsequent transfer of any taxable property shall not authorize any taxpayer to omit the same from his return nor the assessor to fail to assess the same in the manner required, although such return or assessment is not made until after such transfer. When a person or taxpayer engages in business in this state on or after the first day of January, in any year, he shall list all his taxable property, except inventory, as to value, ownership and taxing districts as of the date he engages in business. In listing inventory as to ownership and taxing districts he shall list the probable average value intended to be used in business from the date he engages in business until the first day of January next thereafter. The valuation of all property, including average inventory, to be returned for taxation shall be determined by multiplying the value, or average value of such property by a fraction whose numerator is the number of full months engaged in business during the year of engaging in business, and whose denominator is twelve, unless he shows the assessor, under oath, and by producing a copy of the return or assessment, that the same property has been listed or assessed for taxation for said year in this state.

Section 5711.04 | Time for making returns.
 

(A) Except as otherwise provided in division (B) of the section, returns shall be made, annually, between the fifteenth day of February and the thirtieth day of April. Upon verified application of any taxpayer, and for good cause shown, the county auditor may extend the time within which such taxpayer may make a return to the fifteenth day of June. If the county auditor fails to allow, in whole, a timely application of the taxpayer for an extension of time for filing a return, the taxpayer, upon payment on or before the thirtieth day of April of an amount equal to one-half of the taxpayer's tax for the next preceding year, shall make a return on or before the fifteenth day of June.

(B) When a taxpayer first engages in business in this state after the first day of January in any year, the taxpayer shall make a return within ninety days of commencing such business. Upon verified application of the taxpayer, and for good cause shown, the county auditor may extend the time within which the taxpayer may make the return for a further specified period not exceeding forty-five days.

(C) The county auditor shall certify any extension of time acquired by the taxpayer to the tax commissioner, and the commissioner shall have the same power as to a taxpayer who is required to make return to the commissioner.

Section 5711.05 | Returns of taxable property - fiduciary returns.
 

As used in this section, "legal disability" has the same meaning as in section 2131.02 of the Revised Code.

Each person shall return all the taxable property of which the person is the owner, except property required by this section or the regulations of the tax commissioner to be returned for the person by a fiduciary; but this section does not authorize any person to omit from the person's return of taxable property the person's interest in investments and other taxable intangible property yielding income owned or held for the person's benefit by a fiduciary and not taxed at the source, or other taxable property so owned or held by a nonresident fiduciary. The return of all the taxable property of a corporation shall be made by the president, a vice-president, or the secretary and by the principal accounting officer, that of a partnership, by a partner, and that of an association, by the managing agent in this state.

All taxable property belonging to the persons named or indicated shall be returned by the fiduciaries named, as follows:

(A) That of a ward, by the ward's guardian;

(B) That of a person under a legal disability having no guardian, by the person's father, if living, if not, by the person's mother, if living, and if neither father nor mother is living, by the person having such property in charge;

(C) That of an estate of a deceased person, by the deceased person's executor, administrator, or personal representative;

(D) That of persons whose assets are in the hands of receivers, assignees for the benefit of creditors, trustees in bankruptcy, or official custodians, by such receivers, assignees, trustees in bankruptcy, or official custodians.

Personal property used in business and taxable property of a nonresident used in and arising out of a business transacted for the nonresident or on the nonresident's behalf in any of the cases mentioned in section 5709.03 of the Revised Code, in the possession or custody of any agent, factor, bailee, or other similar fiduciary, shall be returned by such fiduciary, except as is provided by regulation of the commissioner; but as to such property in the possession, custody, or legal ownership of a trustee the next succeeding paragraph of this section shall be exclusive; provided that a warehouseperson shall not be required to return for taxation personal property consigned to the warehouseperson for the sole purpose of being stored or forwarded, if such warehouseperson has no interest in such property other than a warehouseperson's lien, or any profit to be derived from its sale.

All the taxable property, except investments and other taxable intangible property yielding income, of a person for whose benefit property is held in trust shall be returned by the trustee, and if any beneficiary of such a trust is a person under a legal disability residing in this state, and for whom there is no other fiduciary in this state, the commissioner may require such a trustee to return also the investments and other taxable intangible property yielding income held for the benefit of any such beneficiary and not taxed at the source.

All returns made as fiduciaries' returns shall be separate from the fiduciary's return as an individual, firm, association, or corporation and shall set forth the names of all persons toward whom the relation of fiduciary is borne or on whose behalf the returns are made, together with the capacity in which the fiduciary so acts for each of such persons.

The commissioner may adopt and promulgate regulations covering the making of returns not inconsistent with this section or sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, so that all property taxable in this state shall be returned for taxation.

Section 5711.06 | Listing of transferred investments.
 

A taxpayer who during the calendar year has transferred investments to the trustee of a trust fund shall list the investments transferred as to ownership and taxing district as of the date of such transfer, and as to valuation or income yield as of such first day of January; in listing such income yield, such taxpayers may deduct therefrom such portion of the income yield of the equitable interest in such trust fund as is represented by the income received during such year by such trustee from the investments transferred.

Section 5711.07 | Proper taxing district for listing property.
 

Personal property used in business shall be listed and assessed in the taxing district in which such business is carried on. If such business is carried on in more than one taxing district in the same county, the return shall set forth the amount of the property used therein which is situated in each taxing district in such county, and the value of all the personal property used in business shall be apportioned to and assessed in each of such taxing districts in proportion to the value of the personal property situated therein. Domestic animals not used in business shall be listed and assessed in the taxing district where kept. Ships, vessels, boats, and aircraft, and shares and interests therein, shall be listed and assessed in the taxing district in which the owner resides. All other taxable property shall be listed and assessed in the municipal corporation in which the owner resides, or, if the owner resides outside a municipal corporation, then in the county in which the owner resides except as provided in sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code. Whenever, under such sections, taxable property required by this section to be listed and assessed in the taxing district or county in which the owner resides is required to be listed by a fiduciary, such property shall be listed and assessed by such fiduciary in the taxing district or county in which such fiduciary resides, or, in the case of joint fiduciaries, in which either such fiduciary resides; but such property belonging to the estate of a deceased resident of this state shall be listed and assessed in the taxing district or county in which the deceased resident resided at the time of death, regardless of the residence of the deceased resident's executors, administrators, or personal representatives, and such property belonging to a ward, minor, incompetent person, or beneficiary of a trust residing in this state, title, custody, or possession of which is vested in a nonresident fiduciary, shall be listed and assessed in the taxing district or county in which such ward, minor, incompetent person, or beneficiary resides.

As used in this section, "incompetent person" means a person who is so mentally impaired, as a result of a mental or physical illness or disability, as a result of an intellectual disability, or as a result of chronic substance abuse, that the person is incapable of taking proper care of the person's self or property or fails to provide for the person's family or other persons for whom the person is charged by law to provide.

Section 5711.09 | Powers and duties of tax commissioner - contents of return.
 

The tax commissioner shall administer sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, which are laws which he is required to administer within the meaning of sections 5703.19 to 5703.37, 5703.39, 5703.41, and 5703.45 of the Revised Code. He may adopt and promulgate rules not inconsistent with sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, so that all taxable property shall be listed and assessed for taxation. The commissioner shall prescribe the forms of all blank returns consistently with such sections, and no return shall be made or accepted except on the proper prescribed form. Such rules and the forms prescribed may be varied to meet differing local conditions in the counties, but in prescribing such forms the commissioner shall be governed by the following requirements:

(A) No taxpayer shall be required to make more than one return in the same capacity in any one county, but the commissioner may authorize any taxpayer or class of taxpayers to make separate returns for each taxing district within the county.

(B) The listing shall be so arranged as to exhibit clearly the property assessable in each taxing district, and the property assessable on the general tax list and duplicate and on the classified tax list and duplicate.

(C) Questions shall be included which shall elicit a full disclosure of all taxable property of the taxpayer and information relevant to changes in the value of any real estate owned or occupied by him.

(D) All forms of returns required to be made to the county auditor shall have printed, stamped, or written thereon the rates of taxation of property on the general tax list and duplicate in each taxing district in the county, and the day of listing deposits as fixed by the commissioner pursuant to section 5725.05 of the Revised Code.

The enumeration in sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, of facts required to be stated in a return, and questions required to be asked, is not exclusive, but the commissioner may propound any other question in the forms of returns prescribed by him, the answer to which is relevant and material for the purpose of enabling the commissioner, pursuant to Title LVII of the Revised Code, to assess the taxable property of the taxpayer making the return, or that of any other taxpayer, or to administer any of the laws relating to taxation. Each question so propounded shall be answered specifically, and no return shall be accepted by the county auditor until full disclosure has been made as required by such blanks.

Section 5711.10 | Option to file verified federal income tax return.
 

If a taxpayer so elects, he may, under uniform regulations prescribed by the tax commissioner, in lieu of listing his investments yielding income as prescribed in sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code, file with his return a verified summary of his federal income tax return for the last preceding taxable year, if such taxable year was a full year of twelve months, itemized and analyzed in such manner as the commissioner may by such regulations prescribe, together with a statement as to the aggregate amount of income received by him during such taxable year derived from investments taxable under such sections, the income from which is not required to be reported for federal income tax purposes. For purposes of this section, income does not include distributions by an investment company of a gain it realizes on the sale of real property or investments. In such case the aggregate amount of income of the taxpayer from investments of the classes taxable under such sections may be included in the taxpayer's return without specification as to the sources thereof, and shall be taken as the assessment of his investments yielding income, in lieu of the assessment thereof as otherwise prescribed, unless the commissioner finds that such federal income tax return or summary thereof has been improperly made out, in which event the commissioner shall assess such investments on the basis on which the income therefrom should have been reported for federal income purposes, and set forth on the summary thereof, or on the basis on which such investments would be required to be listed and assessed under such sections if the election authorized by this section were not made. If a taxpayer making the election provided in this section is required under section 5711.22 of the Revised Code to list as unproductive investments shares which were not outstanding for the full calendar year next preceding the listing date, he shall deduct from the aggregate amount of his income from investments any income received by him during such calendar year on such shares and on any investments exchanged for or converted to such shares. The commissioner may require that with every return listing investments, the taxpayer shall file a copy of his federal income tax return for the next preceding taxable year, or portions thereof, showing income received by him from investments of the classes taxable under such sections during such year either directly or through fiduciaries. No document authorized or required by this section to be filed with returns of taxable property shall be deemed a public document or record, but shall be a confidential document for the use of the department of taxation only in assessing taxable property; and to that end all such documents filed by a taxpayer shall be enclosed in a sealed envelope or other sealed package addressed to the commissioner which shall not be opened by any person other than the commissioner or his authorized agent, assistant, or employee. The county auditor shall on demand furnish such envelopes or packages of dimensions prescribed by the commissioner.

The commissioner may adopt regulations to govern the use of the basis of listing authorized by this section, but a taxpayer who, after January 1, 1960, avails himself of the option authorized by this section shall thereafter use that basis for a period of not less than three years in listing his investments yielding income. Thereafter, for good cause shown, the commissioner may authorize the substitution of the basis otherwise prescribed by sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code.

Section 5711.101 | Tax commissioner may require financial statement or balance sheet - substitute listing date.
 

The tax commissioner may require that with every return listing personal property used in business or credits, the taxpayer shall file a financial statement or balance sheet of such business as of the close of business on the day next preceding the date of listing.

A taxpayer who is required to file a financial statement or balance sheet of his business pursuant to this section may be authorized or required by the commissioner to list his taxable property as of the close of business at the end of his fiscal year, instead of as of the day otherwise prescribed by section 5711.03 of the Revised Code. The commissioner may adopt regulations to govern the use of the basis of listing authorized by this section, but a taxpayer who is authorized or permitted to list taxable property as of a day other than that prescribed by section 5711.03 of the Revised Code, shall thereafter use the same basis unless the commissioner, for good cause shown, authorizes the substitution of another fiscal year, or, unless the commissioner requires or, upon application of the taxpayer, authorizes, the substitution of another listing date to insure that property subject to taxation under the provisions of section 5709.01 or 5709.02 of the Revised Code, and acquired by means of purchase, merger, or reorganization, involving an entire plant, a facility, or a division, shall not be excluded from taxation for a year or taxed more than once in a year. In the case of such acquisition the commissioner shall require or authorize a substitute listing date only for such acquired property and only for one year.

No document authorized or required by this section to be filed with returns of taxable property shall be deemed a public document or record, but shall be a confidential document for the use of the department of taxation only in assessing taxable property.

Section 5711.11 | Certain returns shall be made in duplicate - county auditor to assess property - returns are confidential.
 

Returns listing personal property used in business or credits shall be made in duplicate. One copy of each return so made shall be retained by the county auditor and the other copy shall be for the use of the tax commissioner. As to all taxable property shown in all other returns required by sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, to be made to the auditor, the auditor shall, as deputy of the commissioner, act as assessor of such taxable property for the purpose of the preliminary assessment thereof, but the commissioner may by order require the auditor to make and transmit to him a copy of a particularly designated return. The auditor shall stamp the date of the making of the return upon each return and copy. Neither the returns nor the copies of returns shall be open to public inspection. The commissioner may require auditors to furnish such statistics and other information as the commissioner may order.

Section 5711.13 | Taxpayer shall make combined return - assessment - certification to treasurer of state.
 

Beginning in tax year 2004, each taxpayer having taxable property with an aggregate taxable value in excess of ten thousand dollars and required to be listed in more than one county shall make a combined return to the tax commissioner listing all its taxable property in this state, in conformity with sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, including property exempt under division (C)(3) of section 5709.01 of the Revised Code, but the taxpayer shall not assign property of the kinds mentioned in section 5709.02 of the Revised Code to any particular taxing district or county. The tax commissioner shall assess the personal property of such taxpayer in the several taxing districts in which it is required to be assessed under sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, and shall issue assessment certificates therefor to the proper county auditors at the time and in the manner required by section 5711.25 of the Revised Code. All other property of such taxpayer required to be so listed shall be entered on the intangible property tax list in the office of the treasurer of state, and shall be subject to taxation under section 5707.03 of the Revised Code. The commissioner shall assess all other property of each such taxpayer and, on or before the second Monday of August annually, shall certify the total value or amount of each kind thereof to the treasurer of state, who shall enter the value or amount on the intangible property tax list in the treasurer of state's office in the manner provided in sections 5725.01 to 5725.26 of the Revised Code. Sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code shall apply to and govern such taxpayer, its proper officers and representatives, the commissioner, and the county auditor as to all proceedings in the assessment of the property of such taxpayer.

Section 5711.131 | County supplemental return.
 

A taxpayer required under section 5711.13 of the Revised Code to file a combined return with the tax commissioner shall, at the time such return is filed, file a county supplemental return with the county auditor of each county in which:

(A) The taxable value of that taxpayer's tangible personal property within any taxing district of the county has increased or decreased in excess of five hundred thousand dollars from that reported by that taxpayer in such taxing district for the preceding tax year; or

(B) The taxpayer, with its return, filed a claim for deduction from book value as provided by section 5711.18 of the Revised Code that would reduce the taxable value in any taxing district in the county by five hundred thousand dollars or more.

The supplemental return shall contain such summary of taxable values as the commissioner by rule requires to enable the county auditor to determine by the first day of July, the increase or decrease in taxable value in each such taxing district in the county for the current tax year. On or before the tenth day of July of each year, the county auditor shall certify to the fiscal officer of each taxing district for which a supplemental return is filed, the change in taxable value in the district in the current tax year as shown on the supplemental returns filed under this section.

Section 5711.14 | Consolidated returns for corporations - joint returns for husband and wife.
 

A corporation which owns or controls at least fifty-one percent of the common stock of another corporation may, under uniform regulations prescribed by the tax commissioner, make a consolidated return for the purpose of sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code. In such case all the taxable property mentioned in section 5709.01 of the Revised Code, belonging to the corporation making the return and to each of its subsidiaries shall be listed and assessed in the name of the separate owners thereof; but the parent corporation making such return shall not be required to list any of its investments in the stocks, securities, and other obligations of its subsidiaries, and in computing the amount of taxable credits inter-company accounts shall be eliminated. The commissioner may adopt regulations to govern the use of consolidated returns authorized by this section, but a corporation which avails itself of the option permitted or authorized by this section shall thereafter continue to file consolidated returns until the parent corporation notifies the commissioner in writing, on or before the twentieth day of April of the year in which the return is due, that it does not intend to file a consolidated return for such year.

A husband and wife living together may, under uniform regulations prescribed by the commissioner, make a joint return for the purpose of sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code. In such case investments of either spouse in the obligations of the other shall not be required to be listed therein, and in computing the amount of taxable credits such obligations shall be eliminated.

Section 5711.15 | Valuation of merchandise offered for sale.
 

A merchant in estimating the value of the personal property held for sale in the course of his business shall take as the criterion the average value of such property, as provided in this section of the Revised Code, which he has had in his possession or under his control during the year ending on the day such property is listed for taxation, or the part of such year during which he was engaged in business. Such average shall be ascertained by taking the amount in value on hand, as nearly as possible, in each month of such year in which he has been engaged in business, adding together such amounts, and dividing the aggregate amount by the number of months that he has been in business during such year.

As used in this section a "merchant" is a person who owns or has in possession or subject to his control personal property within this state with authority to sell it, which has been purchased either in or out of this state, with a view to being sold at an advanced price or profit, or which has been consigned to him from a place out of this state for the purpose of being sold at a place within this state.

Section 5711.16 | Listing of personal property by manufacturer - average value of articles.
 

(A) As used in this section:

(1) "Manufacturer" means a person who purchases, receives, or holds personal property for the purpose of adding to its value by manufacturing, refining, rectifying, or combining different materials with a view of making a gain or profit by so doing.

(2) "Manufacturing equipment" means machinery and equipment, and tools and implements, including any associated patterns, jigs, dies, drawings, and business fixtures, used at a manufacturing facility by a manufacturer, and includes any such property leased to the manufacturer. "Manufacturing equipment" excludes property used for general office purposes. Nothing in this division is to be construed to change the definition of personal property, as defined in section 5701.03 of the Revised Code.

(3) "Manufacturing facility" means a facility or portion of a facility used for manufacturing, mining, refining, rectifying, or combining different materials with a view of making a gain or profit by so doing. "Manufacturing facility" includes that portion of a facility used to store or transport raw materials, work-in-process, or finished goods inventory, for packaging, for research, or to test for quality control, as long as manufacturing, mining, refining, rectifying, or combining is also performed at the facility. "Manufacturing facility" does not include any portion of a facility used primarily for making retail sales.

(4) "Manufacturing inventory" means all articles purchased, received, or otherwise held for the purpose of being used, in whole or in part, in manufacturing, mining, combining, rectifying, or refining, and of all articles that were at any time manufactured or changed in any way by a manufacturer, either by mining, combining, rectifying, refining, or adding thereto.

(B) When a manufacturer is required to return a statement of the amount of the manufacturer's personal property used in business, the manufacturer shall include the average value, estimated as provided in this section, of manufacturing inventory that the manufacturer has had on hand during the year ending on the day the property is listed for taxation annually, or the part of such year during which the manufacturer was engaged in business. The manufacturer shall separately list finished products not kept or stored at the place of manufacture or at a warehouse in the same county.

The average value of such property shall be ascertained by taking the value of all property subject to be listed on the average basis, owned by the manufacturer on the last business day of each month the manufacturer was engaged in business during the year, adding the monthly values together, and dividing the result by the number of months the manufacturer was engaged in such business during the year. The result shall be the average value to be listed.

(C) A manufacturer also shall list all manufacturing equipment owned or used by the manufacturer.

Section 5711.17 | Separate listing of property by manufacturer.
 

All personal property used in business and belonging to a manufacturer, except that required to be listed on the average basis by section 5711.16 of the Revised Code, and that specifically mentioned in such section, shall be listed separately from the property of such manufacturer mentioned in said section.

Section 5711.18 | Valuation of accounts and personal property - procedure - income yield.
 

In the case of accounts receivable, the book value thereof less book reserves shall be listed and shall be taken as the true value thereof unless the assessor finds that such net book value is greater or less than the then true value of such accounts receivable in money. In the case of personal property used in business, the book value thereof less book depreciation at such time shall be listed, and such depreciated book value shall be taken as the true value of such property, unless the assessor finds that such depreciated book value is greater or less than the then true value of such property in money. Claim for any deduction from net book value of accounts receivable or depreciated book value of personal property must be made in writing by the taxpayer at the time of making the taxpayer's return; and when such return is made to the county auditor who is required by sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code, to transmit it to the tax commissioner for assessment, the auditor shall, as deputy of the commissioner, investigate such claim and shall enter thereon, or attach thereto, in such form as the commissioner prescribes, the auditor's findings and recommendations with respect thereto; when such return is made to the commissioner, such claim for deduction from depreciated book value of personal property shall be referred to the auditor, as such deputy, of each county in which the property affected thereby is listed for investigation and report.

Any change in the method of determining true value, as prescribed by the tax commissioner on a prospective basis, shall not be admissible in any judicial or administrative action or proceeding as evidence of value with regard to prior years' taxes. Information about the business, property, or transactions of any taxpayer obtained by the commissioner for the purpose of adopting or modifying any such method shall not be subject to discovery or disclosure.

Section 5711.19 | Determination of trust income - cash distribution.
 

The net income received by a trustee from the sources mentioned in section 5701.10 of the Revised Code shall be determined by deducting all expenses attributable solely to particular sources of gross non-taxable income from the income from such sources, and charging the excess of such expenses over the income from such sources, together with all other expenses and charges, to the taxable gross income from the sources mentioned in such section, provided that trustee fees shall be apportioned between gross taxable and nontaxable sources and charged thereto. If net income is accumulated otherwise than under the circumstances mentioned in section 5711.29 of the Revised Code, such accumulation, and the cash distribution of the remainder of such net income, shall be considered as made pro rata from each source of net income, ascertained as required by this section. Income shall be considered to be distributed in cash if it is withheld by the trustee contrary to the terms of a trust instrument or will or if it is applied by the trustee to the use of the taxpayer, or used by the trustee in paying premiums on policies of insurance on the taxpayer's life, or of which the taxpayer is a beneficiary. Income shall be considered to be distributed in cash, whether such payment or distribution is in cash, notes, debentures, bonds, or other property.

Section 5711.21 | Rules governing assessments.
 

(A) In assessing taxable property the assessor shall be governed by the rules of assessment prescribed by sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code. Wherever any taxable property is required to be assessed at its true value in money or at any percentage of true value, the assessor shall be guided by the statements contained in the taxpayer's return and such other rules and evidence as will enable the assessor to arrive at such true value. Wherever the income yield of taxable property is required to be assessed, and the method of determining between income and return or distribution of principal, or that of allocating expenses in determining net income, or that of ascertaining the source from which partial distributions of income have been made is not expressly prescribed by sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, the assessor shall be guided by the statements contained in the taxpayer's return and such general rules as the tax commissioner adopts to enable the assessor to make such determination.

(B) For tax years before tax year 2009, the true value of the boilers, machinery, equipment, and any personal property used to generate or distribute the electricity shall be the sum of the following:

(1) The true value of the property as it would be determined under this chapter if none of the electricity were distributed to others multiplied by the per cent of the electricity generated in the preceding calendar year that was used by the person who generated it; plus

(2) The true value of the property that is production equipment as it would be determined for an electric company under section 5727.11 of the Revised Code multiplied by the per cent of the electricity generated in the preceding calendar year that was not used by the person who generated it; plus

(3) The true value of the property that is not production equipment as it would be determined for an electric company under section 5727.11 of the Revised Code multiplied by the per cent of the electricity generated in the preceding calendar year that was not used by the person who generated it.

(C) For tax years before tax year 2009, the true value of personal property leased to a public utility or interexchange telecommunications company as defined in section 5727.01 of the Revised Code and used by the utility or interexchange telecommunications company directly in the rendition of a public utility service as defined in division (P) of section 5739.01 of the Revised Code shall be determined in the same manner that the true value of such property is determined under section 5727.11 of the Revised Code if owned by the public utility or interexchange telecommunications company.

Section 5711.22 | Listing and rates of personal property tax.
 

(A) Deposits not taxed at the source shall be listed and assessed at their amount in dollars on the day they are required to be listed. Moneys shall be listed and assessed at the amount thereof in dollars on hand on the day that they are required to be listed. In listing investments, the amount of the income yield of each for the calendar year next preceding the date of listing shall, except as otherwise provided in this chapter, be stated in dollars and cents and the assessment thereof shall be at the amount of such income yield; but any property defined as investments in either division (A) or (B) of section 5701.06 of the Revised Code that has not been outstanding for the full calendar year next preceding the date of listing, except shares of stock of like kind as other shares of the same corporation outstanding for the full calendar year next preceding the date of listing, or which has yielded no income during such calendar year shall be listed and assessed as unproductive investments, at their true value in money on the day that such investments are required to be listed.

Credits and other taxable intangibles shall be listed and assessed at their true value in money on the day as of which the same are required to be listed.

Shares of stock of a bank holding company, as defined in Title 12 U.S.C.A., section 1841, that are required to be listed for taxation under this division and upon which dividends were paid during the year of their issuance, which dividends are subject to taxation under the provisions of Chapter 5747. of the Revised Code, shall be exempt from the intangibles tax for the year immediately succeeding their issuance. If such shares bear dividends the first calendar year after their issuance, which dividends are subject to taxation under the provisions of Chapter 5747. of the Revised Code, it shall be deemed that the nondelinquent intangible property tax pursuant to division (A) of section 5707.04 of the Revised Code was paid on those dividends paid that first calendar year after the issuance of the shares.

(B) For tax years before tax year 2009, boilers, machinery, equipment, and personal property the true value of which is determined under division (B) of section 5711.21 of the Revised Code shall be listed and assessed at an amount equal to the sum of the products determined under divisions (B)(1), (2), and (3) of this section:

(1) Multiply the portion of the true value determined under division (B)(1) of section 5711.21 of the Revised Code by the assessment rate for the tax year in division (G) of this section;

(2) Multiply the portion of the true value determined under division (B)(2) of section 5711.21 of the Revised Code by the assessment rate in section 5727.111 of the Revised Code that is applicable to the production equipment of an electric company;

(3) Multiply the portion of the true value determined under division (B)(3) of section 5711.21 of the Revised Code by the assessment rate in section 5727.111 of the Revised Code that is applicable to the property of an electric company that is not production equipment.

(C) For tax years before tax year 2009, personal property leased to a public utility or interexchange telecommunications company as defined in section 5727.01 of the Revised Code and used directly in the rendition of a public utility service as defined in division (P) of section 5739.01 of the Revised Code shall be listed and assessed at the same percentage of true value in money that such property is required to be assessed by section 5727.111 of the Revised Code if owned by the public utility or interexchange telecommunications company.

(D)(1) Merchandise or an agricultural product shipped from outside this state and held in this state in a warehouse or a place of storage without further manufacturing or processing and for storage only and for shipment outside this state, but that does not qualify as "not used in business in this state" under division (B)(1) or (2) of section 5701.08 of the Revised Code, is nevertheless not used in business in this state for property tax purposes.

(2) Merchandise or an agricultural product owned by a qualified out-of-state person shipped from outside this state and held in this state in a public warehouse without further manufacturing or processing and for temporary storage only and for shipment inside this state, but that does not qualify as "not used in business in this state" under division (B)(1) or (2) of section 5701.08 of the Revised Code, is nevertheless not used in business in this state for property tax purposes.

(3) As used in division (D)(2) of this section:

(a) "Qualified out-of-state person" means a person that does not own, lease, or use property, other than merchandise or an agricultural product described in this division, in this state, and does not have employees, agents, or representatives in this state;

(b) "Public warehouse" means a warehouse in this state that is not subject to the control of or under the supervision of the owner of the merchandise or agricultural product stored in it, or staffed by the owner's employees, and from which the property is to be shipped inside this state.

(E) Personal property valued pursuant to section 5711.15 of the Revised Code and personal property required to be listed on the average basis by division (B) of section 5711.16 of the Revised Code, except property described in division (D) of this section, business fixtures, and furniture not held for sale in the course of business, shall be listed and assessed at twenty-three per cent of its true value in money for tax year 2005 and at the percentage of such true value specified in division (G) of this section for tax year 2006 and each tax year thereafter.

(F) All manufacturing equipment as defined in section 5711.16 of the Revised Code shall be listed and assessed at the following percentage of its true value in money:

(1) For all such property not previously used in business in this state by the owner thereof, or by related member or predecessor of the owner, other than as inventory, before January 1, 2005, zero per cent of true value;

(2) For all other such property, at the percentage of true value specified in division (G) of this section for tax year 2005 and each tax year thereafter.

(G) Unless otherwise provided by law, all other personal property used in business that has not been legally regarded as an improvement on land and considered in arriving at the value of the real property assessed for taxation shall be listed and assessed at the following percentages of true value in money:

(1) For tax year 2005, twenty-five per cent of true value;

(2) For tax year 2006, eighteen and three-fourths per cent of true value;

(3) For tax year 2007, twelve and one-half per cent of true value;

(4) For tax year 2008, six and one-fourth per cent of true value;

(5) For tax year 2009 and each tax year thereafter, zero per cent of true value.

(H)(1) For tax year 2007 and thereafter, all personal property used by a telephone company, telegraph company, or interexchange telecommunications company shall be listed as provided in this chapter and assessed at the following percentages of true value in money:

(a) For tax year 2007, twenty per cent of true value;

(b) For tax year 2008, fifteen per cent of true value;

(c) For tax year 2009, ten per cent of true value;

(d) For tax year 2010, five per cent of true value;

(e) For tax year 2011 and each tax year thereafter, zero per cent of true value.

(2) The property owned by a telephone, telegraph, or telecommunications company shall be apportioned to each appropriate taxing district as provided in section 5727.15 of the Revised Code.

(I) During and after the tax year in which the assessment rate equals zero per cent, the property described in division (E), (F), (G), or (H) of this section shall not be listed for taxation.

(J) Divisions (E), (F), (G), and (H) of this section apply to the property of a person described in divisions (E)(3), (4), and (5) of section 5751.01 of the Revised Code. Division (J) of this section does not prevent the application of the exemption of property from taxation under section 5725.25 or 5725.26 of the Revised Code.

Section 5711.221 | Report of investment income.
 

In listing investments of the kind defined in division (D) of section 5701.06 of the Revised Code, as of the date prescribed by section 5711.03 of the Revised Code, the amount of income yield of each such investment, during the fiscal or calendar year used by the trustee or fiduciary of each such investment shall be stated in dollars and cents and the assessment thereof shall be at the amount of such income yield. The tax commissioner may adopt and promulgate rules and regulations to govern the use of the basis of listing authorized by this section.

Section 5711.23 | Reclassified property assessable.
 

When it has been determined by a board of revision, the tax commissioner, the board of tax appeals, or a court that taxable property which has been listed and assessed for the purpose of taxation as real property for any year should not have been assessed as such, or when any taxable property previously listed and assessed as real property has been removed from the auditor's list of taxable real property or the real property tax list and duplicate, such property shall not be listed and assessed as personal property until the year succeeding that for which such determination was made, or the year succeeding that in which such removal occurred.

Section 5711.24 | Power of tax commissioner to assess taxable property - assessment certificate.
 

The tax commissioner shall assess all taxable property, except property listed in returns which the county auditor is required to assess as his deputy, and shall list and assess all such property which is not returned for taxation, and for that purpose shall have and exercise all powers vested in him by law for the purpose of administering any law which he is required to administer. The action of the assessor in assessing taxable property under sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code, shall be taken as to taxable property required to be listed in a return, whether listed or not, and whether such return has been made or not. Such action shall be evidenced by a preliminary or final assessment certificate in such form as the commissioner prescribes, and when issued by the commissioner it shall be under his official seal. The filing of a return with the county auditor pursuant to sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code, shall be deemed to be the preliminary assessment of the taxable property contained therein when entered on the proper duplicate by the county auditor. Each such certificate shall show in what taxing district in the county such property is assessable, as provided in sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, inclusive, of the Revised Code. Neither such certificate issued by the commissioner nor his action with respect thereto shall be required to be entered on the record of the proceedings of the commissioner, nor shall either be open to public inspection.

Section 5711.25 | Procedure in dealing with assessment certificates - final certificates.
 

On or before the second Monday of August, annually, the tax commissioner shall transmit to the county auditor of each county the preliminary assessment certificates pertaining to the auditor's county of taxpayers having taxable property in more than one county. The commissioner shall transmit to the auditor any amended assessment certificate issued by the commissioner, and the auditor shall transmit to the commissioner copies of all amended assessment certificates made and issued by the auditor. Each preliminary assessment certificate, and if amended such preliminary assessment certificate as last amended, shall become final on the second Monday of August of the second year after the filing of a return with the county auditor or after the certification of the preliminary assessment certificate, or sixty days after the certification of an amended assessment certificate which has been issued less than sixty days prior to such second Monday of August; unless prior to the expiration of said period or extended period one of the following occurred:

(A) A final assessment certificate as to the taxpayer represented thereby has been issued pursuant to section 5711.26 of the Revised Code;

(B) Such taxpayer in writing has waived such time limitation and consented to the issuance of the taxpayer's assessment certificate after the expiration of such time limitation, in which case the assessment certificate issued after the expiration of such time limitation, if an amended preliminary assessment certificate, shall become final sixty days after the mailing of the notice of such assessment if no petition for reassessment of the assessment has been filed pursuant to section 5711.31 of the Revised Code;

(C) A petition for reassessment of the assessment represented thereby has been filed pursuant to section 5711.31 of the Revised Code, in which event the filing of such petition shall waive such time limitation and be a consent to the issuance of the petitioner's final assessment certificate at the time, under the circumstances, and by the authority provided by any law relating to further administrative or judicial review of the assessment represented thereby; provided that in the event of the dismissal of such petition by the petitioner, the assessment shall become final as provided in this section as though no petition for reassessment had been filed. This section does not deprive any taxpayer who has not received the notice prescribed by section 5711.31 of the Revised Code at least sixty days prior to the expiration of such period of limitation of the right to file such petition for reassessment. This section shall apply to all assessments made and certified under sections 5711.01 to 5711.36, 5725.08, and 5725.16 of the Revised Code.

The assessment certificates and copies thereof mentioned in this section shall not be open to public inspection.

Section 5711.26 | Commissioner may make certain final assessments.
 

Except for taxable property concerning the assessment of which an appeal has been filed under section 5717.02 of the Revised Code, the tax commissioner may, within the time limitation in section 5711.25 of the Revised Code, and shall, upon application filed within such time limitation in accordance with the requirements of this section, finally assess the taxable property required to be returned by any taxpayer, financial institution, dealer in intangibles, or domestic insurance company as to which a preliminary or amended assessment has been made by or certified to a county auditor or certified to the treasurer of state or as to which the preliminary assessment is evidenced by a return filed with a county auditor for any prior year; and the commissioner may finally assess the taxable property of a taxpayer, financial institution, dealer in intangibles, or domestic insurance company who has failed to make a return to a county auditor or to the department of taxation in any such year. Application for final assessment shall be filed with the tax commissioner in person or by certified mail. If the application is filed by certified mail, the date of the United States postmark placed on the sender's receipt by the postal employee to whom the application is presented shall be treated as the date of filing. The application shall have attached thereto and incorporated therein by reference a true copy of the most recent preliminary or amended assessment, whether evidenced by certificate or return, to which correction is sought through the issuance of a final assessment certificate. The application shall also have attached thereto and incorporated therein by reference evidence establishing that the taxes, and any penalties and interest thereon, due on such preliminary or amended assessment have been paid. By filing such application within the time prescribed by section 5711.25 of the Revised Code, the taxpayer has waived such time limitation and consented to the issuance of his assessment certificate after the expiration of such time limitation.

For the purpose of issuing a final assessment the commissioner may utilize all facts or information he possesses, and shall certify in the manner prescribed by law a final assessment certificate in such form as the case may require, giving notice thereof by mail to the taxpayer, financial institution, dealer in intangibles, or domestic insurance company. Such final assessment certificate shall set forth, as to each year covered, the amount of the final assessment as to each class of property and the amount of the corresponding preliminary or last amended assessment. If no preliminary or amended assessment was made, the amount listed in the taxpayer's return for each such class of property shall be shown. If the amount of any final assessment of any such class for any year exceeds the amount of the preliminary or amended assessment of such class for such year, the difference shall be designated a "deficiency," and if no preliminary or amended assessment has been made, each item in the final assessment certificate shall be so designated. If the final assessment of any such class for any such year is less in amount than the preliminary or amended assessment thereof for such year, the difference shall be designated an "excess." The commissioner shall add to each such deficiency assessment the penalty provided by law, computed on the amount of such deficiency.

A copy of the final assessment certificate shall be transmitted to the treasurer of state or the proper county auditor, who shall make any corrections to his records and tax lists and duplicates required in accordance therewith and proceed as prescribed by section 5711.32 or 5725.22 of the Revised Code.

An appeal may be taken from any assessment authorized by this section to the board of tax appeals as provided by section 5717.02 of the Revised Code. When such an appeal is filed and the notice of appeal filed with the commissioner has attached thereto and incorporated therein by reference a true copy of any assessment authorized by this section as required by section 5717.02 of the Revised Code, the commissioner shall notify the treasurer of state or the auditor and treasurer of each county having any part of such assessment entered on the tax list or duplicate.

Upon the final determination of an appeal which may be taken from an assessment authorized by this section, the commissioner shall notify the treasurer of state or the proper county auditor of such final determination. The notification may be in the form of a corrected assessment certificate. Upon receipt of the notification, the treasurer of state or the county auditor shall make any corrections to his records and tax lists and duplicates required in accordance therewith and proceed as prescribed by section 5711.32 or 5725.22 of the Revised Code.

The assessment certificates mentioned in this section, and the copies thereof, shall not be open to public inspection.

Section 5711.27 | Penalty assessment for failure to make return or list or disclose all taxable property - personal liability of fiduciary.
 

No taxpayer shall fail to make a return within the time prescribed by law, or as extended pursuant to section 5711.04 of the Revised Code, nor fail to list in a return or disclose on an accompanying balance sheet or in other information filed with the return any item of taxable property the taxpayer is required to list in the return under sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code.

If any taxpayer fails to make a timely return, or fails to list or disclose any item the taxpayer is required to return, the assessor shall add to the assessment of each class or item of taxable property the taxpayer failed to return, list, or disclose a penalty of up to fifty per cent of the assessment; but if such taxpayer makes, within sixty days after the expiration of the time prescribed by such sections, a return or an amended or supplementary return and lists therein or discloses on an accompanying balance sheet or in other information filed with the return all items of taxable property the taxpayer is required by such sections to list, and in all cases in which the taxpayer's only default is the failure to pay the amounts specified in section 5719.02 of the Revised Code within the time therein specified, such penalty shall be five per cent of the assessment, and, if the assessment certificate has been issued, an amended assessment certificate shall be issued and substituted therefor.

The penalty provided in this section may be abated in whole or in part by the assessor when it is shown that such failure is due to reasonable cause. The penalty assessment shall be entered on the proper tax list and duplicate, and taxes shall be levied thereon the same as on the assessment itself.

A fiduciary against whom a penalty assessment is made shall be personally liable for the amount of taxes levied in respect to such penalty assessment and any additional charge, and in case of fraud or intent to evade taxes, such fiduciary shall have no right of reimbursement against the property held by the fiduciary as such fiduciary nor against the person for whose benefit the same is held.

Section 5711.28 | Unreasonable accumulation of profits by corporation - accumulation of trust income - assessment by commissioner.
 

Whenever the assessor imposes a penalty prescribed by section 5711.27 or 5725.17 of the Revised Code, the assessor shall send notice of such penalty assessment to the taxpayer by mail. If the notice also reflects the assessment of any property not listed in or omitted from a return, or the assessment of any item or class of taxable property listed in a return by the taxpayer in excess of the value or amount thereof as so listed, or without allowing a claim duly made for deduction from the net book value of accounts receivable, or depreciated book value of personal property used in business, so listed, and the taxpayer objects to one or more of such corrections in addition to the penalty, the taxpayer shall proceed as prescribed by section 5711.31 of the Revised Code, but if no such correction is reflected in the notice, or if the taxpayer does not object to any such correction made, the taxpayer shall proceed as prescribed herein.

Within sixty days after the mailing of the notice of a penalty assessment prescribed by this section, the taxpayer may file with the tax commissioner, in person or by certified mail, a petition for abatement of such penalty assessment. If the petition is filed by certified mail, the date of the United States postmark placed on the sender's receipt by the postal employee to whom the petition is presented shall be treated as the date of filing. The petition shall have attached thereto and incorporated therein by reference a true copy of the notice of assessment complained of, but the failure to attach a copy of such notice and incorporate it by reference does not invalidate the petition. The petition shall also indicate that the taxpayer's only objection is to the assessed penalty and the reason for such objection.

Upon the filing of a petition for abatement of penalty, the commissioner shall notify the treasurer of state or the auditor and treasurer of each county having any part of the penalty assessment entered on the tax list or duplicate. The commissioner shall review the petition without the need for hearing. If it appears that the failure of the taxpayer to timely return or list as required under this chapter, or to file a complying report and pay tax under Chapter 5725. of the Revised Code, whichever the case may be, was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect, the commissioner may abate in whole or in part the penalty assessment. The commissioner shall transmit a certificate of the commissioner's determination to the taxpayer, and if no appeal is taken therefrom as provided by law, or upon the final determination of an appeal which may be taken, the commissioner shall notify the treasurer of state or the proper county auditor of such final determination. If the final determination orders abatement of the penalty assessment, the notification may be in the form of an amended assessment certificate. Upon receipt of the notification, the treasurer of state or county auditor shall make any corrections to the treasurer's or auditor's records and tax lists and duplicates required in accordance therewith and proceed as prescribed by section 5711.32 or 5725.22 of the Revised Code.

The decision of the commissioner shall be final with respect to the percentage of penalty, if any, the commissioner finds appropriate, but neither the commissioner's decision nor a final judgment of the board of tax appeals or any court to which such final determination may be appealed shall finalize the assessment of such property.

Section 5711.29 | Unreasonable accumulation of profits by corporation - accumulation of trust income - assessment by commissioner.
 

If any corporation uses the rights and powers granted by its charter to prevent the assessment of the shares of its resident shareholders on the basis of income yield, as provided in sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, by permitting its gains and profits to accumulate instead of being distributed, or by paying exorbitant salaries to its officers and employees, the tax commissioner, upon finding such to be the fact, shall assess the amount representing the aggregate assessments of the shares of such resident shareholders in the names of such resident shareholders and certify such assessments, together with the penalty provided in such sections, to the proper county auditor who shall place the same on the classified tax list and duplicate in the names of such shareholders, as investments assessed on the basis of income yield for the year for which such assessments are made; and taxes shall be collected thereon the same as on other like assessments. The commissioner shall give notice of such assessment to the corporation in the manner provided in section 5703.37 of the Revised Code, and such assessment shall be subject to a petition for reassessment and an appeal as provided in sections 5711.31 and 5717.02 of the Revised Code.

If any such corporation is a holding or investment company, or if the gains or profits are permitted to accumulate beyond the reasonable needs of the business, such fact shall be prima-facie evidence of a purpose to prevent the assessment of the shares of its resident stockholders on such basis.

If any trust, under the terms of which the trustee is required or authorized to withhold and accumulate all or any part of the income, is created or used for the purpose of preventing the assessment of the equitable interests of the resident beneficiaries on the basis of income yield, as provided in sections 5711.01 to 5711.36 of the Revised Code, the commissioner, upon finding such to be the fact, shall assess the amount representing the aggregate assessment of such equitable shares in the manner provided in this section. If the creator of such trust reserved a power of revocation, or if the trustee has discretion to pay and distribute the income of the trust property to or for the benefit of such resident beneficiary, such fact shall be prima-facie evidence of a purpose to prevent the assessment of the equitable shares of the resident beneficiaries upon such basis.

The assessment imposed by this action shall not be made against any resident shareholder of such corporation or beneficiary of such trust who in filing the shareholder's or beneficiary's return lists as the income yield of the shares or beneficial interest the entire distributive share or beneficial interest, whether distributed or not, of the net income of such corporation or trust for such year, in which event any subsequent distribution made by such corporation or trust out of the earnings or profits of such year shall, if distributed to any shareholder or beneficiary who has so included in the income yield of the shareholder's or beneficiary's shares the distributive share thereof, be deducted from the income yield of such shares for the year in which the same is made.

Last updated September 12, 2023 at 11:45 AM

Section 5711.30 | Penalty assessment for declaring a nominal dividend or to evade taxes.
 

If any corporation, incorporated under the laws of this state or authorized to do business in this state, declares a nominal dividend or distribution for the purpose of enabling its shareholders residing in this state to return its shares as productive investments, the tax commissioner, upon finding such to be the fact, shall assess against such corporation a penalty equal to a tax of two mills on the dollar of the true value in money of its share of stock owned by shareholders residing in this state. Such penalty shall be collected and distributed in the same manner as taxes levied by section 5707.03 of the Revised Code.

Section 5711.31 | Notice of assessment - petition for reassessment - final determination.
 

Whenever the assessor assesses any property not listed in or omitted from a return, or whenever the assessor assesses any item or class of taxable property listed in a return by the taxpayer in excess of the value or amount thereof as so listed, or without allowing a claim duly made for deduction from the net book value of accounts receivable, or depreciated book value of personal property used in business, so listed, the assessor shall give notice of such assessment to the taxpayer by mail. The mailing of the notice of assessment shall be prima-facie evidence of the receipt of the same by the person to whom such notice is addressed. With the notice, the assessor shall provide instructions on how to petition for reassessment and request a hearing on the petition.

Within sixty days after the mailing of the notice of assessment prescribed in this section, the party assessed may file with the tax commissioner, in person or by certified mail, a written petition for reassessment signed by the party assessed, or by that party's authorized agent having knowledge of the facts. If the petition is filed by certified mail, the date of the United States postmark placed on the sender's receipt by the postal employee to whom the petition is presented shall be treated as the date of filing. The petition shall have attached thereto and incorporated therein by reference a true copy of the notice of assessment complained of, but the failure to attach a copy of such notice and incorporate it by reference does not invalidate the petition. The petition also shall indicate the objections of the party assessed, but additional objections may be raised in writing if received prior to the date shown on the final determination by the commissioner.

Upon receipt of a properly filed petition, the commissioner shall notify the treasurer of state or the auditor and treasurer of each county having any part of the assessment entered on the tax list or duplicate.

If the petitioner requests a hearing on the petition, the commissioner shall assign a time and place for the hearing and notify the petitioner of such time and place, but the commissioner may continue the hearing from time to time as necessary.

The commissioner may make corrections to the assessment, as the commissioner finds proper. The commissioner shall serve a copy of the commissioner's final determination on the petitioner in the manner provided in section 5703.37 of the Revised Code. The commissioner's decision in the matter is final, subject to appeal under section 5717.02 of the Revised Code. The commissioner also shall transmit a copy of the commissioner's final determination to the treasurer of state or applicable county auditor. In the absence of any further appeal, or when a decision of the board of tax appeals or of any court to which the decision has been appealed becomes final, the commissioner shall notify the treasurer of state or the proper county auditor of such final determination. If the final determination orders correction of the assessment, the notification may be in the form of a corrected assessment certificate. Upon receipt of the notification, the treasurer of state or the proper county auditor shall make any corrections to the treasurer's or auditor's records and tax lists and duplicates required in accordance therewith and proceed as prescribed by section 5711.32 or 5725.22 of the Revised Code.

The decision of the commissioner upon such petition for reassessment shall be final with respect to the assessment of all taxable property listed in the return of the taxpayer and shall constitute to that extent the final determination of the commissioner with respect to such assessment. Neither this section nor a final judgment of the board of tax appeals or any court to which such final determination may be appealed shall preclude the subsequent assessment in the manner authorized by law of any taxable property which such taxpayer failed to list in such return, or which the assessor has not theretofore assessed.

As used in this section, "taxpayer" includes financial institutions, dealers in intangibles, and domestic insurance companies as defined in section 5725.01 of the Revised Code.

Section 5711.32 | Correction of records and tax lists.
 

(A)(1) Upon receipt of a preliminary, amended, corrected, or final assessment certificate requiring a correction to his records and tax lists and duplicates, the county auditor shall compute the amount of taxes represented by each deficiency or excess item therein contained at the rate of taxation in effect in the year for which such assessment is made. He shall enter all deficiency items comprised in such assessment certificate on the proper tax lists in his office, together with the amount of taxes so computed thereon, and shall give a certificate of all such amounts to the county treasurer, who shall proceed as prescribed by division (B) of this section. If the assessment certificate comprises any excess items, the auditor shall ascertain whether the taxes, penalties, and interest for the year represented thereby have been paid; if so, he shall proceed as prescribed by division (A)(2) of this section; if not, he shall correct the proper tax lists and duplicates, adjusting any penalties thereon accordingly. If the assessment certificate comprises both deficiency and excess items, he may, after computing the amount of taxes represented by the deficiency and excess items, treat the difference between such amounts as a deficiency or excess for purposes of this section; in such case, the county auditor shall make any adjustment as between the undivided tax funds as is necessary.

(2) If he finds that the taxes, penalties, and interest for the year represented by an excess have been paid, the county auditor shall proceed as prescribed by sections 319.36 and 319.37 of the Revised Code.

(B)(1) Upon receipt of a certificate from the county auditor pursuant to division (A) of this section of the amount of a deficiency, the county treasurer shall proceed in the manner prescribed by division (A) of section 5711.33 of the Revised Code to collect the full amount thereof, including interest thereon, as other like taxes, penalties, and interest, subject to the following exceptions:

(a) If the deficiency includes a penalty assessment for which a petition for abatement of penalty has been filed pursuant to section 5711.28 of the Revised Code, the penalty assessment shall not be collected unless the taxpayer desires to pay it, but the balance of the deficiency, including interest thereon, shall be collected;

(b) If the deficiency is based on an assessment for which a petition for reassessment has been filed pursuant to section 5711.31 of the Revised Code or an appeal has been filed pursuant to section 5717.02 of the Revised Code, no part of the deficiency at issue in such petition or appeal shall be collected unless the taxpayer desires to pay it.

(2) The taxpayer shall pay the full amount of a deficiency required to be collected by the county treasurer under division (B)(1) of this section, less any amount specifically excepted therein, within the time prescribed by division (A) of section 5711.33 of the Revised Code for the collection of like taxes, penalties, and interest. Failure to pay such amount with interest thereon within the time prescribed shall subject such amount, exclusive of interest, to the penalty prescribed by division (B) of section 5711.33 of the Revised Code, and such amount, exclusive of interest, shall continue to accrue interest until paid as prescribed by section 5719.041 of the Revised Code. Any amount of the deficiency specifically excepted from collection under division (B)(1) of this section shall not be subject to the penalty prescribed by division (B) of section 5711.33 of the Revised Code until sixty days after the date of certification by the auditor to the treasurer pursuant to division (C) of this section of the final determination of the petition or appeal excepting such amount from collection under division (B)(1) of this section, but such amount, exclusive of interest, shall continue to accrue interest until paid as prescribed by section 5719.041 of the Revised Code. The taxpayer may make, and the treasurer shall accept, payment of any part of such excepted amount without prejudice to the claims of either the taxpayer, the state, or each county.

(C) Upon receipt of the notification by the tax commissioner pursuant to section 5711.26, 5711.28, or 5711.31 of the Revised Code of the final determination of a petition or an appeal, the county auditor shall make any correction required to his records and tax lists and duplicates and compute the adjustment, if any, required to each deficiency or excess previously certified to the treasurer. He shall forthwith certify to the county treasurer that there has been a final determination and the resulting corrections, if any, to the amount of each deficiency or excess, and the treasurer shall thereupon proceed to collect any unpaid balance. The taxpayer shall pay such unpaid balance, including interest thereon, within sixty days after the date of such certification, and if not so paid within such sixty-day period, the unpaid balance shall be subject to the penalty prescribed by division (B) of section 5711.33 of the Revised Code and shall continue to accrue interest until paid as prescribed by section 5719.041 of the Revised Code.

(D) Notwithstanding divisions (A) to (C) of this section, where the tax commissioner finds the sole reason for the issuance of an assessment certificate with deficiency or excess items is to correct an error that occurred because the taxpayer listed property in the wrong taxing district and the erroneous tax resulting from such error was timely paid, the commissioner shall remit all interest otherwise required to be charged on any tax arising from such deficiency items if the full amount of the deficiency is paid within sixty days after the date of the auditor's certification to the treasurer. If the full amount of such deficiency is not so paid, interest shall be assessed in the same manner and amount as interest would have been charged had this division not been in effect. When refunding the amount of any erroneous tax paid in connection with any excess items included in such an assessment, no interest shall be paid on that amount, notwithstanding provisions of this section, or section 319.36 or 5719.041 of the Revised Code to the contrary. The commissioner shall include on an assessment certificate to which this division applies such information as is necessary to ensure the efficient administration of this division.

Section 5711.33 | Tax bills issued for deficiency assessment.
 

(A)(1) When a county treasurer receives a certificate from a county auditor pursuant to division (A) of section 5711.32 of the Revised Code charging the treasurer with the collection of an amount of taxes due as the result of a deficiency assessment, the treasurer shall immediately prepare and mail a tax bill to the taxpayer owing such tax. The tax bill shall contain the name of the taxpayer; the taxable value, tax rate, and taxes charged for each year being assessed; the total amount of taxes due; the final date payment may be made without additional penalty; and any other information the treasurer considers pertinent or necessary. Taxes due and payable as a result of a deficiency assessment, less any amount specifically excepted from collection under division (B) of section 5711.32 of the Revised Code, shall be paid with interest thereon as prescribed by section 5719.041 of the Revised Code on or before the sixtieth day following the date of issuance of the certificate by the county auditor. The balance of taxes found due and payable after a final determination by the tax commissioner or a final judgment of the board of tax appeals or any court to which such final judgment may be appealed shall be paid with interest thereon as prescribed by section 5719.041 of the Revised Code on or before the sixtieth day following the date of certification by the auditor to the treasurer pursuant to division (C) of section 5711.32 of the Revised Code of such final determination or judgment. Such final dates for payment shall be determined and exhibited on the tax bill by the treasurer.

(2) If, on or before the sixtieth day following the date of a certification of a deficiency assessment under division (A) of section 5711.32 of the Revised Code or of a certification of a final determination or judgment under division (C) of section 5711.32 of the Revised Code, the taxpayer pays the full amount of taxes and interest due at the time of the receipt of certification with respect to that assessment, determination, or judgment, no interest shall accrue or be charged with respect to that assessment, determination, or judgment for the period that begins on the first day of the month in which the certification is made and that ends on the last day of the month preceding the month in which such sixtieth day occurs.

(B) When the taxes charged, as mentioned in division (A) of this section, are not paid within the time prescribed by such division, a penalty of ten per cent of the amount due and unpaid and interest for the period described in division (A)(2) of this section shall accrue at the time the treasurer closes the treasurer's office for business on the last day so prescribed, but if the taxes are paid within ten days subsequent to the last day prescribed, the treasurer shall waive the collection of and the auditor shall remit one-half of the penalty. The treasurer shall not thereafter accept less than the full amount of taxes and penalty except as otherwise authorized by law. Such penalty shall be distributed in the same manner and at the same time as the tax upon which it has accrued. The whole amount collected shall be included in the next succeeding settlement of appropriate taxes.

(C) When the taxes charged, as mentioned in division (A) of this section, remain unpaid after the final date for payment prescribed by such division, such charges shall be deemed to be delinquent taxes. The county auditor shall cause such charges, including the penalty that has accrued pursuant to this section, to be added to the delinquent tax duplicate in accordance with section 5719.04 of the Revised Code.

(D) The county auditor, upon consultation with the county treasurer, shall remit a penalty imposed under division (B) of this section or division (D) of section 5719.03 of the Revised Code for the late payment of taxes when:

(1) The taxpayer could not make timely payment of the tax because of the negligence or error of the county auditor or county treasurer in the performance of a statutory duty relating to the levy or collection of such tax.

(2) In cases other than those described in division (D)(1) of this section, the taxpayer failed to receive a tax bill or a correct tax bill, and the taxpayer made a good faith effort to obtain such bill within thirty days after the last day for payment of the tax.

(3) The tax was not timely paid because of the death or serious injury of the taxpayer, or the taxpayer's confinement in a hospital within sixty days preceding the last day for payment of the tax if, in any case, the tax was subsequently paid within sixty days after the last day for payment of such tax.

(4) The taxpayer demonstrates that the full payment was properly deposited in the mail in sufficient time for the envelope to be postmarked by the United States postal service on or before the last day for payment of such tax. A private meter postmark on an envelope is not a valid postmark for purposes of establishing the date of payment of such tax.

(5) In cases other than those described in divisions (D)(1) to (4) of this section, the taxpayer's failure to make timely payment of the tax is due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect.

(E) The taxpayer, upon application within sixty days after the mailing of the county auditor's decision, may request the tax commissioner to review the denial of the remission of a penalty by the county auditor. The application may be filed in person or by certified mail. If the application is filed by certified mail, the date of the United States postmark placed on the sender's receipt by the postal service shall be treated as the date of filing. The commissioner shall consider the application, determine whether the penalty should be remitted, and certify the determination to the taxpayer and to the county treasurer and county auditor, who shall correct the tax list and duplicate accordingly. The commissioner may issue orders and instructions for the uniform implementation of this section by all county auditors and county treasurers, and such orders and instructions shall be followed by such officers.

Section 5711.34 | List of investment holders in corporations to be filed with tax commissioner.
 

Annually, on or before the fifteenth day of January, the following lists, verified by the president, vice-president, secretary, or the treasurer of the corporation required to file such list, shall be filed with the department of taxation, in such form as the tax commissioner prescribes:

(A) Each corporation incorporated under the laws of this state for profit shall file with the department a list of its shareholders, registered bondholders, debentureholders, noteholders, or other holders of investments in the corporation as defined in section 5701.06 of the Revised Code residing in this state, showing their places of residence and the number of shares, registered bonds, debentures, notes, or other units of investments held by each such holder.

(B) Each corporation incorporated under the laws of this state for profit shall file with the department a list of the persons residing in this state who are shareholders, registered bondholders, debentureholders, noteholders, or other holders of investments as defined in section 5701.06 of the Revised Code of its affiliated foreign corporations, showing the residence and number of shares, registered bonds, debentures, notes, or other units of investments held by each such holder in each such affiliated corporation.

(C) Each foreign corporation for profit doing business in this state, owning or using a part or all of its capital or property in this state, or authorized by the secretary of state to transact business in this state shall file with the department a list of its shareholders, registered bondholders, debentureholders, noteholders, or other holders of investments in the corporation as defined in section 5701.06 of the Revised Code residing in this state, showing their places of residence and the number of shares, registered bonds, debentures, notes or other units of investments held by each such holder.

(D) Each foreign corporation for profit doing business in this state, owning or using a part or all of its capital or property in this state, or authorized by the secretary of state to transact business in this state shall file with the department a list of the persons residing in this state who are shareholders, registered bondholders, debentureholders, noteholders or other holders of investments as defined in section 5701.06 of the Revised Code of its affiliated foreign corporations, showing the residence and number of shares, registered bonds, debentures, notes or other units of investments held by each such holder in each such affiliated corporation.

This section does not require a corporation to file a list of the holders of the kinds of intangible property mentioned herein where the Ohio intangible tax upon such intangible property in said corporation is assessed at its source and paid by such corporation, or a list of holders of unmatured annuities issued by such corporation.

Section 5711.341 | List of investors in money market investment to be filed with tax commissioner.
 

Each trust or other unincorporated issuer of a money market investment sold to residents of this state in the preceding calendar year shall file a list of all its investors in the same manner as required by section 5711.34 of the Revised Code.

No issuer of a money market investment, whether incorporated or unincorporated, that fails to comply with the requirements of this section or section 5711.34 of the Revised Code may be authorized to register, or continue the registration of, any security for sale in this state, from the time that the tax commissioner certifies to the division of securities that such issuer is not in compliance with either of such sections.

As used in this section, "money market investment" means any investment sold under that name or a variant thereof, and any pool of interest-bearing securities in which rights of participation in the distribution of such interest on a pro rata basis are sold by whatever name is used with a promise that they will be repurchased or their principal value otherwise redeemed, with or without the deduction of a fee, by the seller or a contractually specified person, without the requirement of a waiting period other than a reasonable time for the transfer of such funds.

Section 5711.35 | Resident deputy county treasurer.
 

If necessary, the board of county commissioners may provide for the appointment of a resident deputy county treasurer and fix his compensation.

Section 5711.36 | Filing and preservation of returns and assessment certificates.
 

The tax commissioner or the county auditor shall place on file in alphabetical order all returns of taxable property and all assessment certificates, and shall carefully preserve them until five years after the taxes represented thereby have been paid, or litigation concerning the same has been settled, when he shall destroy them.